Man Without Qualities


Wednesday, March 21, 2007


There Are Things More Perverse Than "Hate"

The enactment of laws creating many so-called "hate" crimes has been a priority of many liberals in recent years. The standard model of the type of situation that supposedly must be addressed by such laws projects back to the days of the civil rights movement and beyond: Helpless members of racial minorities (generally but not always African-American) attacked by members of the racial majority motivated by "hate" (often, racial bias). Of course, "hate" crimes are not always limited to racial motiation as the required "hate." Gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity and religious affiliation can also the focus of the "hate." Obviously, private infliction of physical violence against anyone on the basis of any of these grounds is perverse.

But there are more perverse things. One of them is the grossly perverse consequences of the way these "hate" crime laws are actually enforced. That enforcement often (actually, usually) most seriously afflicts members of the very groups the "hate" crime laws were supposedly enacted to protect. Today's news presents a particularly vivid example of this perversity:
A judge sentenced a man to 240 years in prison Wednesday for taking hostages in a bar and telling patrons that "white people are going to burn tonight." State Supreme Court Justice Maxwell Wiley told Steven Johnson, 39, who is black, that he had forfeited his "right to live in society."Johnson, 39, was convicted March 1 of attempted murder, assault and other charges, including some designated as hate crimes.


Isn't it quite enough to punish Mr. Johnson and his ilk for attempted murder, assault and other charges, without designating any of them as hate crimes and bringing in the entire racial mess? Obviously, "hate" crimes cannot just enhance the severity of punishment for crime committed by members of a racial majority against members of a racial minority without running into serious Constitutional problems. That means the laws have to be phrased in facially "neutral" fashion. But that very "neutrality" results in a disproportionate number of members of racial minorities running afoul of these laws (if for no other reason than the statistics of their being in a minority). It's hard to imagine a more perverse result.

Comments:
Have you given up the blog or are you just too busy?
 
More amusing is how liberals try to use any dodge to avoid having hate crimes laws apply to minority perpetrators ... even when their crimes involve racial hate. E.g., a recent crime in New York (as I recall) where black youths shouted racial epithets as they assaulted and robbed a white victim, but the prosecutor said the motivation was primarily "economic" and, thus, not a hate crime. I doubt that would apply were the racial identity of the perpetrators and victim reversed.
 
Well, I've long been an advocate of elimination of all hate crime laws... if for no other reason, than they attempt to tell one what to THINK.

That point aside, it's good to see the law was at least fairly applied in this case.
 
Why is a crime motivated by hate any more heinous than a crime motivated by greed or lust or rage...

As the previous comment stated, every additional minute tacked on to a sentence because of the hate component is punishment for thought.

As a result, there is no way to apply hate crime laws fairly.
 
"...prosecutor said the motivation was primarily 'economic' and, thus, not a hate crime"

Which is very ironic, given that liberals are fond of saying that the primary reason for racism was to justify the economic exploitation of blacks (and of poor whites by giving them someone worse-off to feel superior to and to vent their frustrations upon.) I guess that facts matter only when they serve the left.
 
Nice Post
Gay
 
It was an interesting read. It was thought-provoking. Keep writing!!

This is Nancy from Israeli Uncensored News
 
Good brief and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you on your information.
 
There Are Things More Perverse Than "Hate"

Thanks...
$1 Cheap Porn Site
 
Thanks for the nice article...

There Are Things More Perverse Than "Hate"

Thanks...
MySpace Marketing Secrets Revealed...
 
We brought together the world's top fashion trends of designer jeans to display their charming fashion imagination, creative unique design, to explore the city a unique atmosphere of casual upstart. With its fashion sense, he was ahead of the sensitive integration of the brand concept, the shackles of the traditional dress once released, infiltrated fashion, leisure elements, breaking the traditional framework, and vividly show the self-style, to bring traditional costumes outside the the trend of choice. We have diesel jeans, Ed-hardy jeans, D & G jeans, Levi's jeans and other brands of jeans, first of all to ensure adequate quality and comfort and make the product style and the beautiful, comfortable, classic European and American avant-garde style of the performance of most vividly Cheap jeans allow you to reduce overhead at the same time leading the fashion in our series of jeans, you can create their own unique personality delightful charm.Our center also has jeans diesel, as well as a variety of clothing cheap polo look at the welcome your presence

Truely a nice blog and thanks for your great work.I have carefully read your Bo-wen,By the way,Do you knowcheap shoes store,Many people like it.and Thecheap polo shirtsThey sell are very good,Of course, this also includes theNFL Jerseys.People are like sports, I believe you are also.So,you must be like Cheap Nike Shoesand we are familiar with Air Jordan Shoes.these will make you eyes bright, bring you a special experience.Do NOT miss it!

Truely a nice blog and thanks for your great work. By the way,welcom to our websites:polo shirtsWe providewholesale polo shirtsWholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!All of the product are popular around the world. In addition chaussures puma.Do NOT miss it! Wholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!
 
We brought together the world's top fashion trends of designer jeans to display their charming fashion imagination, creative unique design, to explore the city a unique atmosphere of casual upstart. With its fashion sense, he was ahead of the sensitive integration of the brand concept, the shackles of the traditional dress once released, infiltrated fashion, leisure elements, breaking the traditional framework, and vividly show the self-style, to bring traditional costumes outside the the trend of choice. We have diesel jeans, Ed-hardy jeans, D & G jeans, Levi's jeans and other brands of jeans, first of all to ensure adequate quality and comfort and make the product style and the beautiful, comfortable, classic European and American avant-garde style of the performance of most vividly Cheap jeans allow you to reduce overhead at the same time leading the fashion in our series of jeans, you can create their own unique personality delightful charm.Our center also has jeans diesel, as well as a variety of clothing cheap polo look at the welcome your presence

Truely a nice blog and thanks for your great work.I have carefully read your Bo-wen,By the way,Do you knowcheap shoes store,Many people like it.and Thecheap polo shirtsThey sell are very good,Of course, this also includes theNFL Jerseys.People are like sports, I believe you are also.So,you must be like Cheap Nike Shoesand we are familiar with Air Jordan Shoes.these will make you eyes bright, bring you a special experience.Do NOT miss it!

Truely a nice blog and thanks for your great work. By the way,welcom to our websites:polo shirtsWe providewholesale polo shirtsWholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!All of the product are popular around the world. In addition chaussures puma.Do NOT miss it! Wholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!
 
This site and its content is so nice, i appreciate you from my heart & sole, nice job.
dissertation layout example
 
was Excellent . thaks .
 
was interesting . good luck .
 
Thanks for the post, I enjoyed reading it.
 
Right! Hate is a small child compared with lying and cheating.
 
Fashion Replica Watches company has enlarged its popular lineup Seamaster by Seamaster watches for women who love diving. The New York residents and visitors have a great chance to see and purchase outstanding goods produced by Tiffany at the company's five-floor New York store, where there is enough space to comprise dinnerware and crystals.
 
article that you fit quite interesting & add new value to me
 
Best informations and best Articles and nice design
 
Good post!I'm going to read your other posts. Take care. Keep sharing.
 
very good comment
 
very good comment
 
Hoist by their own petard, eh? Sort of like when a blog owner gets lots of commercial comments. OK, not very much like that.
 
Post a Comment

Home