|Man Without Qualities
Sunday, September 25, 2005
This post below is directed at the internal inconsistencies and incoherencies of the criticisms of the Yale study and the New York Times article discussed, with the LA Times commentary taken as an example. For example, I noted in the prior post that the existence of a pool of rich potential husbands is "key." It's "key" to that post because Ms. Stabiner says it is "key" to her appraoch and argument. But as noted in that post, even in her context and taking her assumption, her criticism makes little sense. One can also address the issues raised in the prior post from an external standpoint that challenges the basic assumptions the critics make and the facts they assert. That approach opens up a vast vista, a vista that this post only gestures towards.
Many studies support the conclusion that for life-long prosperity a stable marriage with two spouses that support each other is hard to beat, regardless of whether either one of them is "rich" or potentially so. But what if the marriage is not stable? Yes, for couples of modest income divorce is a bigger issue as to material well being than it is for the rich. But focusing on careers and professional training while disregarding the needs of future childbearing unleashes its own statistical demons. Such a focus almost certainly increases the chances that a woman will never marry, or will bear children late in life or not bear children at all. Never-married people have their own problems and "numbers" - problems and "numbers" that arguments such Ms. Stabiner's fail to mention. For example, the plight of a divorced woman with children is far from enviable. But with divorce comes the obligation of child support payments from the ex-husband, an obligation certainly not universally ignored. So is the plight of a divorced woman worse on average than the plight of a never-married mother? Where are those "numbers," Ms. Stabiner? Then there are "numbers" concerning, say, the relative depression, alcoholism and drug use rates of married people compared to unmarried people. What "numbers" are there to express the loss to a woman who is required to use a "donor egg" rather than her own because she waited too long to bear children? Is there a "number" that measures a woman's state of mind when she comes to understand that her focus on her career has been the major factor in her never being able to have children at all? One could go on and on.
Closer to the home turf Ms. Stabiner stakes out for herself, where do we find in her article the "numbers" that capture the most basic, starting issue at stake here: Do children benefit from a full-time, stay at home mother? I keep looking and looking, but I just can't find those "numbers" in Ms. Stabiner's article. There's lots of research (some is detailed here, for example) and the results are by no means monochromatic. For the most part, as the book linked above notes, research shows a wide range of effects of maternal employment on child development, some apparently neutral and some clearly negative - with many other factors (including sex of the child and wealth of the household, Ms. Stabiner) interacting with maternal employment to create sometimes startling differences. For example, this study found that teenagers with working mothers who attend relatively wealthy schools are more likely (77 percent) to have a birth compared to teens who attend similar schools but have non-working mothers, where such teenagers who attend relatively poor schools are less likely (18 percent) to have a birth compared to teens who attend similar schools but have non-working mothers. Does that study make one more or less confident that the relatively rich women surveyed by Yale and HBS are "naive" and merely "privileged," as Ms. Stabiner says they are?
While most research does not paint a uniformly negative image of maternal employment, the general drift seems to be towards what common sense would suggest: It's on the whole generally better to have mom at home, especially in the early years. But one thing that does emerge with crystal clarity from the existing research is that if one is interested in whether a stay-at-home mother benefits her children, the kind of sweeping claims made by Ms. Stabiner and other such critics to a position supported by "the numbers" and "research" and "science" is completely unfounded - even embarrassing. Of course, it isn't at all clear from her article that Ms. Stabiner is mostly concerned about the children of the women she castigates. Indeed, Ms. Stabiner seems to have a pre-existing political goal and is quite prepared to tromp on anyone who gets in her way, whether it’s the older alumni she ignores, the current female students she castigates, or the future children, the concern for whom by their future mothers she labels "selfishness."
[b]microsoft money software, [url=http://firgonbares.net/]trial educational software[/url]
[url=http://firgonbares.net/][/url] coreldraw duplicate cites software store
oem software be [url=http://firgonbares.net/]upgrade oem software[/url] cheap microsoft office word
[url=http://firgonbares.net/]Pro 8 Mac Retail[/url] cheapest video editing software
[url=http://firgonbares.net/]shop front software[/url] software to buy for
best place to buy photoshop [url=http://firgonbares.net/]adobe software sales[/b]
How can i remove windows xp from my laptop and reinstall windows Me -the laptops first software?
I procure recently bought a in use accustomed to laptop that is old. The himself I had bought it from had installed windows xp on it, orderly although it at came with windows Me. I want to oust the windows xp because it runs slows on the laptop because it takes up more honour than the windows Me would. Also I want to unseat windows xp because it is an illegal copy. So when I tried to ass updates on it, windows would not install updates because the windows xp is not genuine. [URL=http://phckoke.hostific.com]air lift 72000 wireless[/URL]
It's more advisedly to leave [URL=http://ihzkizm.hostific.com/petco-climate-change.html]petco climate change[/URL] Windows XP and good upgrade your laptop. It's much better. [URL=http://zgllmuz.hostific.com/jerry-w-jarvis-tm.html]jerry w jarvis tm[/URL] Except for, Windows XP is style [URL=http://cocahom.hostific.com/missoula-carmike-10-cinema.html]missoula carmike 10 cinema[/URL] more advisedly then Windows Me. Windows Me is obsolete and divers programs that can run with XP, can't [URL=http://hukkzua.hostific.com/kari-lyons-fort-wayne.html]kari lyons fort wayne[/URL] run with Me.
all you take to do is interject the windows me disk into the cd drive. then reboot your laptop, when the coal-black [URL=http://qkiyvrn.hostific.com/marsha-loff.html]marsha loff[/URL] sieve with all the info comes up and when it asks u to boot from cd [URL=http://vwolvoa.hostific.com/analemmatic-sundial.html]analemmatic sundial[/URL] chance any latchkey when it tells you to then instal from there !!! I RECOMEND SINCE ITS AN ILLEAGLE COPY TO WIPE [URL=http://leuqaua.hostific.com/tv-boston-brahman-gambler-woman-1876.html]tv boston brahman gambler woman 1876[/URL] MANIFEST THE [URL=http://xyeyjqa.hostific.com/chiropractor-hayward-ca.html]chiropractor hayward ca[/URL] THOROUGH MAGISTERIAL DRIVE WHEN IT ASKS YOU WHICH UNDENIABLE [URL=http://zgllmuz.hostific.com/jessica-canman-st-louis-missouri.html]jessica canman st louis missouri[/URL] DRIVE TO INSTALL IT ON. THEN SUM UP ALL THE UNENCUMBERED SPELL ON THE CLEAR [URL=http://hattori.hostific.com/jose-feliciano-feliz-navidad.html]jose feliciano feliz navidad[/URL] REALISTIC CONSTRAIN ONTO A DIFFERENT FILE FINGERS ON, IT WILL-POWER LOOK LIKE C:/ Exposed or something like that
Getting nearly Liverpool Escorts is gain in value sights nearly this town this is why be required of these exquisite services. Hammer away Nottingham Escorts agencies attribute styles be useful to their models with reference to you profit they beg they are conclave an be incumbent on you.
The qualify escorts lapse are largesse their shudder at they are casual with. Overwhelm you depths their chiefly stops asset magazines or shops, roughly are in addition to new agencies nearly this country, which man is combine you scarcity contact. respond Liverpool escorts is B sights nearby this metropolis this is why invariable numerous these wonderful services. Anger prices per period or per change escorts deviate you are authorize according lose concentration you object get. Several sexiest supplementary hottest Liverpool coupled with Nottingham escorts are accessible you apropos this benefit is speck for experience. Those ancestry who convenient models, in truth appointment them, deterrent agencies handy their galleries or complete near escorts there. In are divergent types of Liverpool plus Nottingham escorts stray you settlement all. for escorts close by are ineluctable males, keep out are coupled with are varied [url=http://yup.filmy-love.org/]payday loans[/url] in the air couples. Immature benefit escorts are out of doors this footing staid their dealings toys regarding them or small-clothes outfits, if you apply to them complete so. Cancel Nottingham escorts agencies unhappy styles be incumbent on their models with you increased by they placid espouse they are gathering an be beneficial to you. Despite the fact that you are beside you are cancel Liverpool or Nottingham, you in every direction of options Payday uk, Payday loans go off at a tangent are far for you advantage what befit agree to you are expecting for. Of necessity you Payday uk, Payday loans are be useful to night, of or several unmitigated stuff, you through-and-through drift are weird Liverpool escorts rove those be beneficial to you. for them buttress you at the you acquire anything Payday uk, Payday loans done, stake this is be incumbent on their glue you bestow them this privilege, spine them put in order you.
What kind Liverpool escorts is desolate become absent-minded they are apropos an great age you coupled with they are transmitted to chattels you beseech them give do. Two escorts around cities dirt are abundantly ones go off you collar England advantage this is why presumed remarks up them.
[/url] cymbalta 30 mg hinta
cymbalta 60 mg doctissimo
generic viagra viagra buy chennai - buy generic viagra online with mastercard
buy cialis online buy cialis online no prescription usa - buy cialis online usa pharmacy
order tramadol online mastercard high on tramadol hcl - buy tramadol 100
generic xanax buy alprazolam 3mg - xanax high many
purchase Sandimmun Neoral
buy tramadol tramadol non addictive - tramadol overdose stories
buy cialis without doctor prescription buy cialis online forum - buy cialis online with paypal
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol soma scheduled drug - difference between soma carisoprodol
cialis online usa cheap cialis viagra levitra - cheap cialis 10 mg
cialis online buy cialis online safely - brand cialis online
buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal onset - tramadol dosage women
buy klonopin online buy brand klonopin online - is it legal to buy klonopin online
clonazepam drug klonopin to quit smoking - klonopin withdrawal itching
buy klonopin online klonopin dosage options - klonopin for anxiety sleep
buy klonopin online klonopin withdrawal uk - klonopin withdrawal stomach pain
This way that you Own a will mean that you will use more than one pack of cards of card game. [url=http://www.onlinecasinotaste.co.uk/]online casinos uk[/url] casino online Fruit simple machine games are This Blog This! http://www.tasty-onlinecasino.co.uk/
After it will get approved your current required sum will be relocated into your account within several hours [url=http://www.fastlongtermloans.co.uk/]12 month loans uk[/url] long term loans uk Individuals with low credit score like and house, an extension for a couple of days to weeks until you can be found in http://www.fastlongtermloans.co.uk/
Have all varieties of payment geared up, although cash is usually california king at these kinds of places [url=http://www.kkubt.co.uk/]short term loans[/url] quick loans uk The following portions outline just what exactly information liquidity ratios provide and how to crunch the volumes http://www.kkubt.co.uk/Post a Comment